Whose “Place” Is it Anyway?

I have just finished a terrifically positive, inspiring conversation with Ethan Gelber, co-founder of the Local Travel Movement in which we recognized that the essence of his movement and Conscious Travel is the same.

  • All travel purchases are made locally even if the benefits do not always stay there.
  • Travel is motivated by the differences that exist between origin and destination – we travel to see somewhere different than home. As the industrial model tends, over time, to standardize and homogenize, it contains within it the seeds of its own destruction. The Local Travel Movement is one path towards celebrating what makes a Place unique and scarce and, therefore, more valuable to guests and generate a higher return to hosts.
  • Conscious Travel focuses on supporting hosts in celebrating and differentiating their “PLACES” as this is the only way in which they will be truly valued and can return real net benefit to all.

Not long after putting down the phone, my attention was drawn to the plight of the Cinqueterra.

This beautiful part of Italy appears under threat from a minority of its own locals. A local population of some 5000 residents is responsible for protecting what has been recognized as a world heritage site from the greed of a few “locals” who wish to tap into short term income associated with 3 million visitors. Years of work associated with revitalizing local crafts, developing local food and crafts and the creation and maintenance of a National Park have been halted. The region’s economy has suffered from the recession (caused largely by greedy bankers located miles away) and flashflooding.

It seems that a little tourism can be a good thing – when I visited the area in 1969, the villages were poverty stricken and in a state of dilapidation. A tourism industry provide the economic rationale for their restoration. But too much tourism can be harmful. More is not always better. Two communities, Vernazza and Monterosso along with the mountain paths that connect the five communities, were severely damaged in the storms of October 11th. While tourism activity was negatively affected, some also cite tourism along with climate change as a cause of the damage. Regular mantenace of the terraced hillsides has lagged as residents turn to more lucrative and less onerous occupations than farming. In 1951, about 3,500 acres were cultivated in the Cinque Terre. Today, there are fewer than 275.

I write this post in the hopes that my readers will share the link to the source of the video below. Film makers, Kristie Lee Weller and Sharon Boeckle of Harvestfilms, who had already chronicled the revitalization of the local economy, are seeking to raise $2500 to film the current conflict and draw attention to the issue.  Click here  to see the film and here to read their blog. 


http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1965817586/vendemmia-a-documentary-film/widget/video.html

The second reason for writing is to open up the conversation regarding the question: whose place is it anyway? Do non-residents like me and the American film-makers have the right or a responsibility to influence local opinion and show we care? If a place can be recognized as being of global significance, what safeguards and support can and should be given to local communities to protect that which is deemed as scarce?  The opinion broker, AVAAZ, has been effective in demonstrating that a global community can influence, even determine what happens in a locality.  How does that fit with an ethos of “self-determination” when local preference might be equated with “self-destruction” ??? Note: some of these questions parallel those raised in Andy Jerosz blog Challenges That Occur When You Meet the Locals discussed earlier here.

Regardless of your response to these questions, I urge you to help these film makers document the issue and its possible resolution. Given the doubling of tourism (as forecast by the UNWTO), you can safely expect that the Cinque Terra story will be commonplace and we’d better be ready to deal with this conundrum all over the world.

POSTCRIPT
For up to date information about Cinque Terra, please visit
http://www.cinqueterre.com/blogc

3 Responses to “Whose “Place” Is it Anyway?”

  1. In the short run, these villages need visitors to sustain the local economy and support services and an injection of cash to help rebuild. Tragically, tourists often avoid a place that has suffered a hazardous event at the very time when their presence could really help recovery.

    The longer term challenge will be one of balancing demand with what is clearly a limited supply. The role of Destination Marketing Organizations needs to switch to Destination Management.

  2. Hello Anna,
    Your post got me thinking. I like many have visited the Cinqueterra and like everybody I’m sure have been charmed by their beauty. And, as you know, I’m an avid conscious capitalist. However, your post brought up the question for me: do we always need to travel in the direction of long-term sustainability over short-term income? I wonder about this. What if short-termism (for want of a better word) is exactly what that country/company/community/’place’ needs at that particular point in time, due to its context or circumstances, to help it survive best? To be interchanged with ‘long-termism’ as the next step along the path, perhaps followed by ‘short-termism’ again thereafter. A sort of interchangeable dance that ensures survival and flourishing in the evolution of life. It strikes me that we may (myself included) be at risk of making short-termism wrong and long-termism right, but in so doing we cut out one half of the whole that exists in everything. Surely, I reason with myself, the question is not whether we do one over the other, but rather whether or not we do whatever we do with conscious choice? In this regard, I wonder whether the question is not: ‘are we acting in the long or the short term interests’, but rather ‘are we acting in a way that serves the sustainability of the whole – whatever that act may be’? I guess this is my definition of radical free choice. When I look at the animals in the wilds of Africa, where I currently live, death and demise is as much a part of life as birth and growth, all necessary for the whole to survive, flourish and expand. Perhaps our job then is to ask ourselves: what do I need to do around here that guarantees the evolution of life in this Place? and ensure that I am acting from here and not out of my identity’s or ‘small self’s’ fears and needs which result in greed and not caring about my impact on the whole.
    Thanks for a great and thought-provoking post.
    Best wishes,
    Gina

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Forget branding – let people, place & personality shine through | Conscious.Travel - November 16, 2012

    […] Whose Place is it Anyway? […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: